Pizza is my favorite food. When it comes to pizza, Pensacola might just surprise you. While we’re famous for our white-sand beaches and fresh Gulf seafood, the city’s pizza scene is a vibrant mix of styles, from classic New York slices to authentic wood-fired Neapolitan pies. Check out my picks for best pizza in Pensacola.
Best Pizza in Pensacola
Founaris Bros. Greek Restaurant
Founaris Bros. Greek Restaurant serves delicious Greek pizza in Pensacola. I personally love feta cheese on a pizza, but if you don’t, there are options without, or have them leave it off. The Vegetarian and Cheese are my favorites, but if you prefer to have meat on your pizza, the Super 7 is a wonderful choice.
Location: 6911 Pensacola Blvd, Pensacola FL 32505
Hours:
Tuesday – Saturday: 11am – 9pm
Sunday: 11am – 3pm
Sky’s Pizza Pie
Sky’s Pizza Pie serves up the closest thing to New York Style pizza in Pensacola. You can order by the pie or the slice. Their pies range from 16-24 inch and the slices are perfect for folding. The Bianca, and Margherita are a couple of my favorites, along with the garlic knots. Sky’s offers daily specials to check out when you plan your next pizza night, especially if you are looking for an extra-large pizza to feed your family.
Location: 5559 N Davis Hwy, Pensacola, FL 32503
Hours:
Monday – Thursday: 11am – 9:30pm
Friday – Saturday: 11am – 10pm
New Yorker Deli & Pizzeria
New Yorker Deli & Pizzeria offers a mix of soups, salads, sandwiches, pasta dishes and pizza in Pensacola. The pizza is made with their own sauce and hand-tossed dough. They come in 12 or 16 inch, and a 10-inch gluten free cauliflower crust is also available. The Athenian, New Yorker Special and Vegetarian are excellent. When the weather is pleasant, the best seating is outdoors on their patio.
Location: 3001 E Cervantes St, Pensacola, FL 32563
Hours: Monday – Saturday 11am – 9pm
Boomerang Pizza Kitchen
Boomerang Pizza Kitchen serves brick oven pizza along with salads, appetizers and calzones. The atmosphere and experience when dining in Boomerang is what makes the pizza so special. The restaurant is reminiscent of a 50s retro kitchen. Enjoy your pizza on cherry pattern melamine plates, which are also available for purchase in their shop attached to the restaurant. I love spending time in the shop looking at old board games, toys and trinkets from the 50s.
Location: 5227 Willing St, Milton, FL 32570
Hours:
Sunday, Tuesday – Thursday: 11am – 8pm
Friday – Saturday: 11am – 9pm
The Tuscan Oven
The Tuscan Oven stands out as a pizzeria in Pensacola’s pizza scene, offering an authentic taste of Italy right on North 9th Avenue. What sets this family-owned pizzeria apart is their imported, two-ton, wood-fired oven. This unique cooking method infuses each pizza with a distinct smoky flavor and creates a perfectly crispy yet chewy crust, characteristic of true southern Italian style.
Location: 4801 N 9th Ave, Pensacola, FL 32503
Hours:
Tuesday – Thursday: 11am – 8:30pm
Friday – Saturday: 11am – 9:30pm
Subscribe to Our Weekly Events Newsletter
Ready to soak up more sunshine, savor more local flavor, and stay in the loop on what’s happening around town? Don’t forget to subscribe to our weekly events newsletter for the latest food finds, outdoor gems, and all things Pensacola. Let’s make every week an adventure—Your Oasis. Your Community. Your Pcola.
